Homemade Yogurt

Photo: sobodda
A couple weeks ago I presented a video tutorial on making Homemade Cheese from a recipe I got from my godmother (Greek Orthodox). Well she also gave me a couple more great milk based Greek recipes while she was at it. One of these is Homemade Yogurt.
Making yogurt is something I have been waiting to tackle for some time now, but the weather has been all but permitting. When making yogurt from this recipe you must let it sit out in a very warm area, so it has been too cold. Now that June has approached and this heat advisory has rolled up on us here in Philadelphia, the perfect yogurt making weather has come.
Ingredients
- 1 Gallon Whole Milk or 2% depending on preference
- Small Package Quality yogurt that has “active cultures” that is plain with no fruit or sugar added
Procedure
- To begin bring 1 Gallon of milk to a simmer.
- Mix 3 tablespoons of yogurt to one cup of warmed milk.
- Once mixed, Add the remainder of warmed milk.
- Leave and let rest 6 or more hours, with lid on, in very warm area with no draft, to thicken until a water appears on top.
- Hang the yogurt up in cheese cloth to remove liquid until desired thickness is reached (approximately 4-6 hours)
- Chill and Serve.
For a more Greek style yogurt let hang for the greater portion of time. The more whey that drains the thicker the yogurt will be. You can also use a splash of white wine vinegar to help the curds separate from the whey with a dash of salt.
This yogurt can replace sour cream and milk in recipes and is excellent served with fresh fruit, raisins, nuts or sweetened jams.
Shelf life is usually 2 weeks, but I would keep a close eye.
Enjoy!
-Jimi
If your interested in other milk based Greek recipes:
- Feta: My post on homemade cheese, just substitute the cows milk for raw goats milk.
You may also be interested in our article on Vitamin D in Milk
Never Miss An Article!
Enter your email address and subscribe to Rooftop Kitchen:
Add A Blog Have your own food, garden or environmental themed blog? Join the community and add your blog to our blogroll.
Posted by Jimi on June 10th, 2008 and filed under cook, recipe.


Homemade Yogurt | Rooftop Kitchen…
…homemade Greek style yogurt recipe……
is it very cost effective to make your own yogurt? how much of the whey drains off? Do you catch it and use it for anything?
Hello Colleen,
Not much of the whey gets strained out. Your let with maybe around 14 or 15 cups.
Regarding coast effectively,
A gallon of milk cost me about $4.
The active yogurt was $.89.
So roughly $5 for 14 cups or $.36 per cup (8oz)
As for the leftover whey with the yogurt, I usually mix it with diced tomatoes and peppers and make a little spread with it.
If you have larger amounts you could use it as a soup base.